The Paradox of Authenticity: Balancing Who You Are with What Your Team Needs
By VICKY BROWN
“Just be yourself” is often touted as the ultimate leadership advice. But what happens when being yourself doesn’t align with what your team needs from you in the moment? This is the paradox many leaders face—balancing authenticity with adaptability. As your business grows, so does the complexity of your leadership role. And showing up as the exact same version of yourself in every situation may not serve your team—or you.
In this article, we explore how authentic leadership for business owners isn’t about staying static, but about staying rooted in your values while stretching your leadership style to meet evolving challenges. Being real doesn’t mean being rigid. It means being intentional about how you show up, especially when the stakes are high.
What Does Authentic Leadership Really Mean?
Authenticity in leadership is often misunderstood. It doesn’t mean sharing every thought that crosses your mind or always operating on instinct. True authentic leadership is about congruence—the alignment between your values, your intentions, and your actions.
It means your team can trust that the person they’re seeing is genuinely invested in the mission, consistent in values, and emotionally grounded—even when circumstances change. It also means being self-aware enough to evolve. Who you were as a leader when you started your business shouldn’t be exactly who you are today.
Leadership is a dynamic role. And as your business scales, the kind of leadership it needs from you will evolve too. Authenticity must keep pace with that growth—not get left behind.
The Risk of Over-Identifying with “Who You Are”
Many leaders unintentionally box themselves in with statements like “That’s just how I am” or “I’m not comfortable doing that.” While self-awareness is important, clinging to fixed traits can prevent growth. A leadership style that worked with two employees may not work with twenty. The mindset that helped launch your company may not help it scale.
For example, maybe you’re naturally conflict-avoidant, preferring harmony over confrontation. That doesn’t make you a bad leader—but if your team needs clarity or direct feedback, avoiding hard conversations isn’t serving them. In moments like this, growth doesn’t mean losing your authenticity—it means expanding it.
The version of you that micromanaged your first employee might now be learning to delegate and build trust across a larger team. That’s not inauthentic—that’s growth.
Leadership Is About Range, Not Rigidity
One of the most important lessons in authentic leadership for business owners is this: you need range. Your team doesn’t need you to act the same way in every scenario. They need you to be responsive to the moment—whether that means being calm and steady during a crisis, or energized and visionary during a strategy session.
This concept is sometimes compared to code-switching, but not in a performative way. It’s about expressing the same core values—respect, fairness, clarity—in different ways depending on the audience and the context. Your tone, delivery, and energy can (and should) shift based on what the situation calls for.
The key is intentionality. You’re not being fake—you’re being flexible.
“… The best leaders aren’t one-dimensional. They’re evolving, responsive, and deeply connected to both their personal values and their team’s needs“
How to Expand Without Losing Yourself
You can grow your leadership range without losing your foundation. The goal is to stretch, not to shape-shift. Here are a few ways to begin:
- Anchor in Your Values
Know what matters most to you as a leader. When you’re clear on your principles, you can adjust your delivery without losing your center. - Choose Intentional Expression
Instead of defaulting to your comfort zone, pause and ask: “What does this moment require from me?” Then respond in a way that reflects your values and serves the situation. - Create a Feedback Loop
Trusted team members, mentors, or advisors can help you see where your style may be helping—or hurting—your impact. Feedback helps bridge the gap between how you intend to show up and how you’re actually perceived. - Reflect and Adjust
After big conversations, decisions, or meetings, ask yourself: “Did I lead in a way that served the team? Did I stay true to my values? What could I have done differently?”
Whether you’re an entrepreneur jumping into a leadership role, a seasoned business pro with new HR responsibilities, or just starting your HR career – we’ve got the right path to guide you through your HR hurdles.
Check out the Leaders Journey Experience. This online education platform holds the LJE Masterclass, HR SimpleStart Academy and HR FuturePro Academy.
Not sure where to start – take the quiz!
Why This Matters for Business Owners
Your leadership sets the tone for your entire company. If your team sees you as adaptable, grounded, and growth-oriented, they’re more likely to follow your lead. If they sense you’re stuck in habits that no longer serve the business, they’ll eventually mirror that stagnation.
Authentic leadership for business owners isn’t about making everyone like you—it’s about being someone they can count on. And that reliability comes from your ability to adapt to their needs without betraying your own values.
This also builds trust. When people see that you can shift gears without losing your integrity, they know they’re in capable hands. It allows your team to grow with you, rather than around you.
Final Thoughts
Authenticity isn’t about staying the same—it’s about staying aligned. The best leaders aren’t one-dimensional. They’re evolving, responsive, and deeply connected to both their personal values and their team’s needs.
If you’ve been struggling with how to “be yourself” while also being effective, start by redefining what authenticity means. It’s not about comfort. It’s about congruence. It’s not about always being the same. It’s about always being intentional.
The paradox of authenticity is not a choice between being real or being a strong leader. It’s an invitation to become both. And in today’s fast-moving business world, that combination is what sets exceptional leaders apart.