DE&I – What's an Employer to Do?
By VICKY BROWN
The conversation around DE&I—Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion—has become increasingly complex for employers. Once viewed as a straightforward way to build stronger teams and more equitable workplaces, DE&I is now caught in a crossfire of cultural tension and legal scrutiny. As an employer, it can feel like you’re walking a tightrope between your values and your legal obligations.
So what’s a business owner to do? Should you pull back on DE&I efforts altogether to avoid potential risk? Or double down in a way that aligns with your company’s mission, while still staying compliant? The good news is—you don’t have to choose one or the other. With the right approach, you can protect your business while still building a workplace that reflects your values.
Why the DE&I Landscape Has Changed
Over the past few years, DE&I programs have come under sharper legal focus, particularly from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). The shift is important: DE&I is no longer viewed just through the lens of good intentions or corporate responsibility. It’s now part of how your organization is evaluated for legal compliance.
The EEOC has made it clear that any employment decision influenced—even in part—by a protected characteristic (such as race, sex, or religion) could now be scrutinized. This means that initiatives like hiring “targets,” race-specific mentorships, or exclusive employee groups can trigger legal risk, especially if they appear to exclude others based on identity.
Programs that once felt like a powerful way to support underrepresented employees are now being questioned—and in some cases, challenged in court. What used to be considered progressive strategy might now expose your business to discrimination claims, regardless of your intent.
Understanding the Compliance Risk for Small Businesses
Small businesses often assume they’re too small to face the same level of risk as large corporations. That’s a dangerous assumption. Legal exposure doesn’t require a large team or a national platform. In fact, small businesses can be particularly vulnerable, because they often lack formal HR teams or legal departments to provide regular oversight.
What’s more, things that may seem harmless—such as sharing demographic data in your marketing, asking vendors about their DE&I efforts, or forming employee groups with limited membership—are now on the EEOC’s radar. Even well-meaning programs that appear to favor certain groups over others may be viewed as discriminatory under the law.
So if you’ve been promoting your DE&I values in your job postings, or highlighting the makeup of your team in investor reports, now’s the time to revisit that strategy. Not to abandon it, but to ensure it’s structured in a way that’s legally sound.
Balancing Compliance and Inclusion
Let’s be clear—none of this means you have to give up on DE&I. But it does mean you need to be thoughtful and strategic in how you implement those efforts. It starts with redefining what inclusion really means for your business.
True inclusion isn’t about excluding one group to uplift another. It’s about creating environments where all people—regardless of identity—feel valued, heard, and empowered to succeed. That means using behavior-based approaches rather than demographic quotas. It means opening the door for everyone to participate in conversations around equity, rather than segmenting your workforce by identity.
For example, instead of forming closed employee resource groups, allow all employees to join while still maintaining the original mission of the group. Or instead of setting demographic hiring quotas, focus on expanding your recruiting channels to reach a more diverse pool of candidates while applying the same hiring standards to all.
“… The EEOC has made it clear that any employment decision influenced—even in part—by a protected characteristic (such as race, sex, or religion) could now be scrutinized.”
Practical Steps for Employers
If you want to promote inclusion without compromising your compliance, here are a few foundational actions to consider:
- Audit Your Current DE&I Practices
Review your existing programs, policies, and communications. Are they inclusive of everyone? Do they suggest preference based on identity? Work with legal counsel to ensure your practices are aligned with current regulations. - Reframe Your Messaging
Move from identity-based goals to inclusion-based language. Emphasize a workplace culture that values diverse perspectives, collaboration, and fairness for all team members. - Standardize Policies and Programs
Whether it’s hiring, promotions, or employee support programs—consistency is key. Document your processes clearly and apply them evenly. Avoid informal practices that might suggest favoritism. - Train Your Team—Including Managers
Make sure everyone involved in hiring, evaluation, or team leadership understands what compliance means in the context of DE&I. Microlearning modules or short trainings can be incredibly effective in raising awareness. - Model Inclusive Leadership
Show your team that inclusion isn’t a trend—it’s a value. Ask for feedback, seek different viewpoints, and demonstrate openness in your own behavior. Leadership sets the tone for company culture.
Whether you’re an entrepreneur jumping into a leadership role, a seasoned business pro with new HR responsibilities, or just starting your HR career – we’ve got the right path to guide you through your HR hurdles.
Check out the Leaders Journey Experience. This online education platform holds the LJE Masterclass, HR SimpleStart Academy and HR FuturePro Academy.
Not sure where to start – take the quiz!
Values-Driven Doesn’t Mean Risky
One of the biggest fears among business owners is that prioritizing DE&I will put them at legal risk. But the truth is, it’s not the values that are the problem—it’s the execution.
You can absolutely mentor underrepresented founders, provide growth opportunities for early-career professionals, or support community outreach programs—without excluding others or applying different standards within your company. The key is to make sure your workplace policies reflect equity of access and consistency of practice.
When DE&I is implemented through this lens, it becomes a business strength rather than a liability. It fosters trust, improves performance, and attracts the kind of talent that thrives in healthy, inclusive environments.
Final Thoughts
DE&I is not a dirty word, and it doesn’t have to be a legal minefield. But it does require a more nuanced approach than ever before. As a business leader, your challenge is to align your commitment to inclusion with the legal responsibilities you carry as an employer.
Start by reframing how you think about inclusion—not as a set of boxes to check, but as a guiding principle for building better teams and stronger companies. And remember, compliance isn’t the ceiling. It’s the floor. What you build on top of it is entirely up to you.